The Hamptons, known for its pristine beaches, luxurious estates, and vibrant culture, is not just a playground for the rich and famous. It’s also a haven for coffee enthusiasts looking to start their day with a perfectly brewed cup of joe.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll take you on a caffeine-infused journey to uncover the best coffee in the Hamptons. But first, let’s dive into some travel tips to make the most of your visit to this idyllic destination.
Best Coffee in the Hamptons
Travel Tips for Your Hamptons Getaway
Plan Your Visit: The Hamptons experience varies throughout the year. Summer is the peak season, offering beach activities and lively events, while spring and fall bring pleasant weather and fewer crowds. Winter is the quietest, perfect for a serene escape.
Transportation: Depending on your location, the Hamptons can be reached by car, train, or bus. The Hampton Jitney and Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) offer convenient options for those traveling from New York City.
Accommodations: Book your accommodations in advance, especially during the summer months when demand is high. Options range from upscale resorts to charming bed and breakfasts.
Explore Beyond Coffee: While coffee is a must, don’t forget to explore the Hamptons’ stunning beaches, art galleries, and local markets. The area is also rich in history, with historic sites and museums waiting to be discovered.
Now that you’re prepared for your Hamptons adventure, let’s explore the best coffee spots in the area.
1. Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee – Amagansett
Address: 146 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930
When you’re in the Hamptons, kickstart your coffee quest at Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee in Amagansett. This beloved coffee shop is famous for its commitment to sustainability and organic, fair-trade beans.
The cozy ambiance and friendly staff create a warm atmosphere to enjoy your hand-crafted latte or cappuccino. Pair your coffee with a freshly baked pastry for the ultimate morning treat.
Image Credit: @KaiserBrit TripAdvisor
2. Left Hand Coffee – Montauk
Address: 83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954
A trip to the Hamptons wouldn’t be complete without a visit to Montauk, and while you’re there, stop by Left Hand Coffee. This local gem is tucked away from the bustling town center, providing a tranquil spot to savor your coffee.
The minimalist décor and expertly roasted beans make for a delightful coffee experience. Don’t forget to explore the scenic Montauk Point State Park nearby after your caffeine fix.
Image Credit: @Billysalts TripAdvisor
3. Sagtown Coffee – Sag Harbor
Address: 78 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Sag Harbor exudes old-world charm, and Sagtown Coffee fits perfectly into this picturesque village. This coffee shop is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Their selection of beans from renowned roasters ensures a diverse coffee menu.
Take your coffee to-go and stroll down Main Street, exploring the quaint boutiques and historic architecture that make Sag Harbor so special.
Image Credit: @Sagtown TripAdvisor
4. Hampton Coffee Company – Water Mill
Address: 869 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976
The Hampton Coffee Company is a beloved institution in the Hamptons, known for its exceptional brews and welcoming atmosphere. This family-owned business roasts its beans in-house, ensuring a fresh and flavorful cup every time.
The Water Mill location offers a spacious outdoor seating area, perfect for enjoying your coffee while soaking up the Hamptons’ sunshine.
Image Credit: @Phil T TripAdvisor
5. Hampton Chutney Co. – Amagansett
Address: 6 Amagansett Sq, Amagansett, NY 11930
For a unique coffee experience with an Indian twist, head to Hampton Chutney Co. in Amagansett. This charming café serves up not only delicious coffee but also inventive dosas, a South Indian specialty.
The combination of their signature “Madras Filter Coffee” and a dosa is a must-try culinary adventure.
Image Credit: @HamptonChutneyCo TripAdvisor
6. Golden Pear Café – East Hampton
Address: 34 Newtown Ln, East Hampton, NY 11937
A visit to the Hamptons wouldn’t be complete without stopping by the Golden Pear Café in East Hampton. This iconic spot has been serving locals and tourists for over 30 years.
Beyond their excellent coffee, their menu offers a variety of freshly prepared sandwiches, salads, and pastries. It’s the perfect place to refuel during your day of exploring.
Image Credit: @Colin P TripAdvisor
7. The Golden Pear Café – Southampton
Address: 99 Main St, Southampton, NY 11968
Another branch of the Golden Pear Café can be found in Southampton, offering the same exceptional coffee and delectable menu as its East Hampton counterpart. Grab a seat on the outdoor patio and watch the world go by as you sip your favorite brew.
Afterward, explore the charming boutiques and art galleries that line Main Street.
Image Credit: @Peter R TripAdvisor
8. Golden Pear Café – Bridgehampton
Address: 2426 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
The Golden Pear Café has a presence in Bridgehampton as well, making it convenient for coffee lovers exploring the eastern parts of the Hamptons. Stop by for a morning coffee, and don’t forget to try their renowned iced coffee—a refreshing treat on a warm summer day.
Image Credit: @Puravida_7 TripAdvisor
9. Bliss Kitchen – Sag Harbor
Address: 41 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Bliss Kitchen in Sag Harbor offers an alternative coffee experience with a focus on wellness. They serve organic coffee alongside a range of healthy and delicious options, including smoothie bowls, salads, and fresh juices.
It’s the perfect spot for those looking to balance their caffeine fix with nutritious choices.
Image Credit: @KaiserBrit TripAdvisor
In conclusion, the Hamptons offers not only pristine beaches and upscale living but also a thriving coffee culture waiting to be explored. Whether you’re sipping your latte in Amagansett, Montauk, Sag Harbor, or elsewhere in the Hamptons, each coffee shop brings its unique charm and flavor to the table.
So, as you embark on your Hamptons adventure, be sure to include a coffee quest in your itinerary—you might just discover your new favorite brew amidst the seaside splendor.
Discover more guides:
